American Idol Recap: The Best Top 6 Ever, But Who Saved Themself?

American Idol Recap: The Best Top 6 Ever, But Who Saved Themself?
Recap and Commentary by Idolhead Ed
April 26, 2012

Sure he bounced around the stage like a pro but the vocal was just OK. Not even close to standing O status.

If Josh goes home or is even in the bottom 3 it will be because of the standing O’s.

Making the public think he will be safe no matter what is a dangerous thing.

Elise: “I Want It All”
Elise will win the prize tonight for finding the most obscure of songs and trying to pass them off and well known.

I have never heard this Queen song but in this case it didn’t matter because she sang the hell out of it and it was great.

Everything was there; the vocal the passion and the smile.

I was hoping for a more melodic song but this was very good and it did get back a little to the “Whole Lotta Love” vibe.

Could it keep her safe?
Grade A

Phillip: “Fat Bottom Girls”
As Steven said this was Phillip. Nothing straying too far from his usual acorn tree.

It was sung well enough but a poor song choice especially after the group song of this was killed.

But that won’t hurt him. As we see he is singing next to last.

I guess they don’t want him to get Coltoned.
Grade B

Hollie: “Save Me”
Here we go again with one of those prophetic song titles.

If this were her only song of the night that would be her cry for sure.

This was standard Hollie fare but that means it was also pitchy. Bad? Not by any means.

There are seasons past this would be held up as a season’s best of.
Grade B-

And now we move into the second round.

Jessica: “Dance With My Father”
This has been sung before by Scott Savol, Jacob Lusk and most recently by Jermaine Jones.

I have to agree with Jen this is the best it has ever been sung on the show.

Jen thinks it’s the best ever. I think when we look at What Not To Sing’s numbers tomorrow she will have the highest ever score on this song.

For all you Jess haters.....

Continued On Next Page

Send Press Releases, Tips, News, Gossip: Click Here

Reality TV Headlines | Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Staff Information | RSS Feed

All listings are subject to change.
Site Design and Programing Copyright 2003 - 2012© Reality TV Calendar, all rights reserved.

All articles are the intellectual property of and copyrighted by the individual authors.
By submitting an article to Reality TV Calendar you are granting Reality TV Calendar
permission to display the article in perpetuity.

Free Countercasino